Russian Reading Update: Another female writer – does Kollontai show that Teffi isn’t alone?

bookshelf_bannerWhen I first heard of ‘Love of Worker Bees’ I was so excited because I hadn’t yet discovered Teffi and was feeling terribly guilty about the gender imbalance in my Russian reading.  I realise it’s not Kollontai’s fault that I then learned of Pushkin Press’s publication of ‘Subtly Worded’. I’m going to try not to judge Kollontai harshly by comparison, but it won’t be easy.

Alexandra Kollontai was a fascinating woman.  Just days after the Bolsheviks seized power she became the People’s Commissar of Social Welfare, the first woman in Russia ever to hold such a high ranking post.  Although she was eventually sidelined politically, she nonetheless made her mark, most famously because of her revolutionary theories around love, sex and marriage.  Kollontai clearly had no truck with the pure and celibate ‘marriage of minds’ espoused (if you’ll excuse the pun) by Chernyshevsky and Lenin. ‘Love of Worker Bees’ is where she uses fiction to explain what Orlando Figes calls her ‘little…understood’ and ‘highly idealistic’ theories of sexual emancipation.

imgres

Kollontai believed that ‘sexuality is a human instinct as natural as hunger or thirst.’ So the three stories in this book are filled with infidelity, followed by jealousy followed by understanding and acceptance.  Given that there had just been a socialist revolution, you can understand why Kollontai had hope that her theories might be understood and accepted, but, while I applaud her views on sexual equality, I do wish she was better at characterisation.  The majority of the writers I’ve looked at in this project are great story-tellers, the minority were political theorists who realised that fiction is a good way to appeal to the masses.  Essentially Kollontai’s book is of historical and social interest, but I can’t stay it stands up on literary merit alone.

Also, and again, this is a reflection on me not her, as well as reading Teffi recently, I’ve also read Paull’s ‘The Bees‘ this year, which has no relation to Kollontai’s book at all, except for the fact that I found her title a continual distraction.

So there we are, ‘Love of Worker Bees’ is a short book and an interesting book, but if you want to read a great female Russian writer, read Teffi.  On the other hand, I may well be looking out for a biography of Kollontai to really learn about her contribution to Russia at this time.

image

Alexandra Kollontai 1872-1952

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Reading in translation, Russian Reading and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Russian Reading Update: Another female writer – does Kollontai show that Teffi isn’t alone?

  1. MarinaSofia says:

    Kollontai is absolutely fascinating – but had a bit of a sad fate as she was soon marginalised after the Soviet Revolution started losing its idealism and got mired in authoritarianism. I don’t think Ive read much by her, but would love to find out more about her.

    • She’s the only writer I think I’ll be covering who was writing from such an insider view. Of course, the effect has been that I now I want an outsider’s opinion of her own life!

  2. kaggsysbookishramblings says:

    Kollontai was an inspiring woman. Not as good a writer as Teffi, but she was writing from a polemical point of view and her book “A Great Love” (a roman a clef about Lenin and Inessa Armand) is fascinating because of the insider’s view it gives.

  3. I remember reading this many years ago when I was drawn to revolutionary literature, and agree with MarinaSofia, she was a fascinating woman – but the fact I can remember nothing about the book probably says a lot!…………but, the fact I have just managed to track it down on my shelves means it may make a re-read within my soon to be revealed challenge, at some point.

    • Ooh – a new challenge! I can’t wait to follow along.
      As for ‘Love of Worker Bees’, I’d be very surprised if the story lines stay with me as the years pass … hopefully the info about Kollontai will though, she does sound like a fascinating woman.

      • First post of it tomorrow. It is frighteningly long, almost as long as the book itself. I do think reading with some kind of other hat on, so that you aren’t considering a book in isolation, but in connection to all sorts of other things, means reading (and reviewing) a little differently. If all my reading the twentieth end up being as detailed I will revise the timescale to 20 years. And i will be in my dotage by then, no doubt!

  4. Stefanie says:

    She sounds like a fascinating woman, too bad her fiction isn’t so very good!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s