The Future of Fiction is Bright Indeed: ‘The Shore’ by Sara Taylor (2015)


‘The Shore’ caught my eye earlier this year because, well, why woudn’t it with a cover that fabulous?  I mentally filed away the name and then let things simmer until I saw it reappear, not on a bookshelf, but in the shortlist for the Peters, Fraser and Dunlop/Sunday Times ‘Young Writer Award’.  It was back at the top of the reading pile and I’m so so grateful because I couldn’t have started December with a better book.

Screen Shot 2015-11-28 at 20.11.00

‘The Shore’ has been described as a collection of short stories and as a novel. It doesn’t really matter which definition you follow, as the book takes the best from both forms, combining the distilled clarity of the short story with the sustained structure of a novel spanning decades and generations.  At the start of the book is a family tree and each chapter deals with one or more members of the sprawling and dysfunctional tribe.  If you will, it is a condensed Rougon Macquart cycle for our times, allowing Taylor to explore heredity, society, melodramatic violence and mystical hope through a single family who dominate and are dominated by their geographical location.

Going with another analogy, the book deals with the impoverished and brutalised population of the American hinterland.  I was frequently reminded of the award-winning ‘Winter’s Bone’, a film which shows a society equally poised between claustrophobia and isolation, where violence is commonplace and the law is very far away.


The first story ‘Target Practice’ sets the tone and quality of the whole book:
When news of the murder breaks I’m in Matthew’s, buying chicken necks so my little sister Renee and I can go crabbing.  There isn’t much in the way of food in the house, but we found a dollar and sixty-three cents in change, and decided free crabs would get us the most food for that money.  Usually we use bacon rinds for bait, but we’ve eaten those already.
As Renee listens to the gossip about the murder she notes ‘my necks are starting to drip blood and chicken ooze through their newspaper onto my leg‘.  Then she goes home to practice shooting.  There is violence in nearly every story in the book, but it is everyday, as much a part of the landscape as the storms, the wild horses and the meth labs.  Women are walking targets, ‘Skirt’ begins ominously with the lines ‘She shouldn’t have been wearing a skirt, Bo said to us after.  It was her own damn fault’, but no one is safe; I don’t think I’ve ever read a book with so much castration.

As the stories jump forward and back in time a wonderful tension is set up between the claustrophobia and the idea of escape promised by the island existence.  The richness of the natural resources is contrasted powerfully with the economic hardship and rigid societal hierarchies.  Times change (chronologically, the stories move far into the future) but the constraints and freedom of the setting are a constant.  Everyone in the book exists within this liminal space, partly belonging to the state of Virginia and partly creatures of the wild, with all of the power and vulnerability this entails.

The Young Writers prize is going to be awarded today.  I do hope ‘The Shore’ will give me a hat trick for agreeing with the judges in 2015 (I loved the Bailey’s winning ‘How to Be Both‘ and managed to get it right with ‘A Brief History of Seven Killings’), however, even if I don’t get my choice, I’ll still have the enjoyment of a truly wonderful book.  As for the intimidating title of this specific prize, it’s a reminder that all of the authors nominated are under 35.  I’m sure everyone who’s read ‘The Shore’ will be joining me in hoping that we will see much more from Taylor for many years to come.

This entry was posted in Gothic Literature, Sara Taylor, Young Writer Award and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

17 Responses to The Future of Fiction is Bright Indeed: ‘The Shore’ by Sara Taylor (2015)

  1. Wonderful review – The Shore is definitely one of my top reads of the year. The comparison with Winter’s Bone hadn’t occurred to me but you’re absolutely right. I hope she wins – it will be very much deserved!

  2. Nish says:

    Wow! This book sounds amazing, and I love that cover. Have to look out for it now.

  3. Brilliant review of brilliant book

  4. FictionFan says:

    Great review – the book sounds wonderful! Have you read Winter’s Bone? I’ve heard conflicting reports of it and keep adding it to the TBR and taking it off again – it sounds as if it also might be pretty graphic in the violence department, and I’m pretty sure castration has been mentioned in connection with it too… odd, but intriguing…

    • To my shame, I hadn’t even realised WB was originally a book until I saw your comment. If it’s anything like the film it will be pretty gruelling. On the other hand, ‘The Shore’ certainly had its graphic moments and was utterly wonderful…

  5. I haven’t read The Shore but it is next to me on the coffee table right now! I just read and loved The Year of the Runaways. Wow.

    • ‘The Year of the Runaways’ was the Booker short-lister that got away. I read all of the others and then this was one very long volume too far. It sounds like I should keep it on the TBR pile though – really looking forward to your review!

  6. Sarah says:

    Wow, after reading your review ‘The Shore’ is a ‘must read’ for the new year. It sounds gripping and visceral, and what a stunning cover!

  7. Aquileana says:

    After reading this trend topic and the comments on this post, I´d love to read `The Shore`…
    I will definitely keep it in mind… thanks for sharing. Merry Christmas and all my best wishes to you. Aquileana 🎄

  8. Pingback: Of art and artists: Anna North’s ‘The Life and Death of Sophie Stark’ (2015) | Shoshi's Book Blog

  9. Pingback: Another must-read from Sara Taylor: ‘The Lauras’ 2016 | Shoshi's Book Blog

Leave a Reply to orangepekoereviews Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s