Beyond ‘Brokeback Mountain’: ‘Close Range: Wyoming Stories’ by Annie Proulx


I have been meaning to read ‘Close Range’ for years.  I even managed to kid myself that I’d read most of it, when I found a stand-alone edition of ‘Brokeback Mountain’, the last novella in the collection, at my local library.  Now that I have the real thing though, I can speak down to my former self, ‘Brokeback’ might be tender, bitter and sublime, but it is only a part of the fierce glory of the whole ‘Wyoming Stories.’

The insular, brutal lives of the characters are especially striking given the current tenor of American politics.  Characters very rarely leave their home territory.  In ‘A Lonely Coast’ the narrator remembers her one vacation outside the state ‘to Oregon where my brother lived … up the lonely coast a stuttering blink warned ships away.  I said to Riley that was what we needed in Wyoming – lighthouses.  He said no, what we needed was a wall around the state and turrets with machine guns in them.‘  As with states, so with people; the collections’ characters are walled off from each other, trapped as much in society as they are by the lonely and never-ending landscape around them.  We see how those who don’t fit in become victims, but also how even the most secure must endure daily hardship.  In the twisted and brilliant ‘People in Hell Just Want a Drink of Water’ for example, incidental detail creates a distressing portrait of deprivation with ‘Bliss, who had not tasted candy until he was fourteen and then spat it out, saying, too much taste.’ 

The stories aren’t all about misery and violence though, or at least, they’re not only about misery and violence.  There are laugh-out-loud moments of comedy, summed up in the deadpan ’55 Miles to the Gas Pump’; I don’t want to give away the punchline, but this two page story was a highlight of the collection.  There are also fantastical elements, with magical spurs and an abandoned tractor whose interactions with a lonely girl are far more shocking than the realist setting would lead you to expect.  I still have a hard time reconciling my imagination with the events in ‘The Bunchgrass at the Edge of the World,’ but that doesn’t mean I don’t love it.

Proulx’s most recent novel, ‘Barkskins’ (reviewed here) has been long-listed for the Bailey’s Prize.  ‘Barkskins’ is a epic novel about the American forests.  It is an ambitious book with an attractive premise, but I know the ‘Close Range’ is going to be more of a personal favourite.  It may present a less clear cut and sympathetic message, but despite, or perhaps because of this, it is utterly enthralling.  Even while I’m yearning for pleasant escapism in my reading, the visceral stories in this collection have touched me and pulled me back into a dark and lonely world that is somehow still alive with love, majesty and magic.

This entry was posted in Annie Proulx, Reading America, Short story collections and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Beyond ‘Brokeback Mountain’: ‘Close Range: Wyoming Stories’ by Annie Proulx

  1. It’s been ages since I read this, and as you point out, it could be a pertinent time for a re-read. I do think Proulx is a master of the short story – just breathaking in what she achieves in such a small space.

  2. Izzy says:

    I have a feeling I ought to know who Annie Proulx is, but I don’t. An American writer, apparently, with a French name… I’ve never come across any of her books. I’m going to look her up because this collection sounds ‘awesome’

    • It is – Annie Proulx has written a lot, but not much recently. She is probably most famous for this collection (especially after the film was made of ‘Brokeback Mountain’) and of her novel ‘The Shipping News’ which is simply brilliant.

  3. Jim Bannon says:

    I’ve been a fan of Annie Proulx ever since reading Shippping News years ago. I recently came across a copy (signed) of Close Range but there’s something odd about her autograph. She signed it “Annie” followed by what looks like “Prouduct” or “Producti” which is crossed out with a single line the wrote “Proulx” above it. A mystery for sure but I’m very happy to own the book

  4. Pingback: A Classic Western: ‘Lonesome Dove’ by Larry McMurtry | Shoshi's Book Blog

Leave a Reply to Jim Bannon Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s